All images courtesy of Nick & Toni’s.


Since the late eighties, Nick & Toni’s has been a mainstay of East Hampton. Their Tuscan farmhouse setting, extensive drink offerings, and wood burning oven, make for a quintessentially Hamptons experience.

From their menu, we can recommend the Penne alla Vecchia Bettola as a surefire win, and it’s even available gluten-free. For something that’s true to the flavors of the east end, we’d go with the Rohan Duck Milanese, adorned in part by fresh black mission figs. On the dessert side, you can’t go wrong with the Strawberry Upside Down Cake, or the Tartufo (for two), but really, you’re not going to want to share either of them. 

Pro Tip: split a pizza as an appetizer.


136 Main St.
East Hampton, NY 11937

PHONE: (631) 324-3550


INSTAGRAM: @nickandtonis

Want more exclusive Hamptons content? We’ve got you.

For features on the latest and best Hamptons events, parties, pop-ups, restaurant openings and more, check out our FEATURES section.

For insider perspectives on life out east from celebrities, VIPs, influencers and other Hamptons notables, subscribe to the OUT EAST VIBES podcast.

We’ve rounded up the best bars, restaurants, hotels and sweet treat spots in the Hamptons and put them on a single, easily searchable list for you. Interested? Check out Dune Road Lifestyle’s TOP PICKS and see what you’ve been missing out on.

Dune Road Lifestyle was founded to bring you the best of the Hamptons: all killer, no filler. We take a minimalist, details-focused approach to product, travel and lifestyle journalism that most sites, well, don’t. We don’t bombard you with a million ads and pop-ups. We don’t invade your e-mail. We want our site to be like the Hamptons itself: easy, refreshing, and chic.

Want to tell us how we’re doing? Got an idea for a feature, podcast guest, or place to review? Hit us via e-mail at or on Insta at @duneroadlifestyle.